10 Custard Powder Substitute (With Surprisingly Perfect Texture)

If you are wondering about the different ways that you can substitute custard powder with other ingredients, then you should consider the following information. The truth of the matter is, that there are many substitutes that you can use for custard powder.

If you have read other information about custard powder substitutes, you may not have heard of secondary or subcategory substitutes to enhance the flavor of your recipes.

Generally, custard powder is used to create a quick crosscut from traditional custard recipes. In other words, this is a great way to make the process of baking (or cooking) faster without all the headaches of making traditional custard.

Here are 10 substitutes for custard powder that you can integrate into many recipes!

Cornstarch

Cornstarch is one of the premier custard powder substitutes, and it can be used in a variety of recipes that require a thickening agent.

The science behind cornstarch is rather simple and can be easily understood.

The science behind cornstarch can help to reveal if this is the best choice for your recipes as a substitute.

Firstly, when using cornstarch as a custard powder substitute, you should understand the recipe that you’re intending to use thoroughly. Cornstarch has a distinct flavor that’s very mild.

Likewise, the flavor of the corn that has been used during the wet-milling process of production will affect your recipe greatly. Also, if you’re looking for a gluten-free substitute, this may not be the best choice.

This is because starch and gluten are very important for high-quality cornstarch development. Depending on the recipe that the cornstarch will be used, it is the starch and gluten that causes many ingredients to rise higher.

Additionally, if you’re looking for an emulsifier for fats and proteins, then cornstarch may be the right choice.

LEARN MORE: 10 Pinto Bean Substitutes

Tapioca Flour

Tapioca flour is made from arrowroot and potato starches. It can be used as a thickening agent for cookie doughs, different types of gravy, sauces, and an array of puddings.

It isn’t the same as cornstarch and will yield a different flavor for your recipes.

Food-grade tapioca flour is generally made from cassava roots as well.

This means it is a substitute that is best for biscuits, pastries, loaves of bread, and different types of cakes. The texture of tapioca flour is different than cornstarch and has a stingier consistency.

If your recipe is for a dessert and foods that are more delicate, tapioca flour can be a substitute compared to cornstarch.

Water-Chestnut Flour

Water chestnut flour is made from chestnuts that have been ground down into flour. They are typically roasted before being made into flour.

You must be very careful when using water chestnut flour because mature chestnut trees in the United States have been extinct for many decades.

If your recipe requires additional seeds or nuts, then water chestnut flour can be integrated into the recipe accordingly.

Water chestnut flour has a slightly nutty flavor and can be integrated into cake recipes, cookies, and making different soups.

The nutritional value of water chestnut flour is considerably good and can be used as a substitute in many dough recipes instead of custard powder.

Source: sciencing.com

Fresh Eggs and Organic Milk

Some recipes have a distinct taste that cannot be altered in any way, or it will destroy the entire taste of the dish.

If this is the case, you can make your custard with free-range eggs and organic milk.

If you cannot find free-range eggs and organic milk, standard egg, and whole milk choices will do.

Typically, when your fresh custard, it will not be as yellow as the powdered version. When looking for fresh custard recipes that require eggs and milk, look for recipes without as much sugar or a way to substitute the sugar.

This is because if your recipe already has requirements for sugar and you add additional sugar into your fresh custard recipe, the result can be extra sweet.

LEARN MORE: 10 Matzo Meal Substitutes

Baking Soda

There is a lot of debate concerning using baking soda as a custard powder recipe.

However, it is possible to use baking soda as a substitute if you are careful not to add too much.

For instance, if your recipe requires two tablespoons of custard powder, you can use the same amount of baking soda as a substitute.

The idea is to use the same amount of baking soda as you would custard powder. To have the same flair as custard flour and look, you can use a little natural yellow food coloring.

In addition, to enhance the taste, you can add vanilla bean, vanilla flavoring, or a small amount of vanilla extract.

Pastries Cream

Pastry cream is an excellent substitute for fresh custard or custard powder.

There are many recipes for pastry cream available online and in several recipe books.

When finding a pastry cream substitute for any custard powder, it is important to keep in mind what the end insult will be like if you add this substitute.

Pastry cream is generally made like fresh custard. The standard recipe for pastry cream usually has first eggs, sugar, cornstarch, milk, and sometimes vanilla beans for additional flavor.

If you notice, many pastry cream recipes call for cornstarch. If you would like, it may be possible to use only cornstarch as a substitute.

If you could start using pastry cream instead to replace powdered custard, the result would be noticed in the flavor tremendously. Also, keep in mind that using pastry cream can add to the moisture content of a recipe.

Pudding Mix

Using pudding can be an inexpensive way to substitute fresh custard or custard powder in a recipe.

Pudding mix or potting powders are available in many flavors.

Generally, vanilla mixes are used instead of custard powder. It is possible to use other pudding mix flavors instead of custard powder.

Yet, if you desire to keep the flavor true to the recipe, it is best to use the aforementioned, vanilla flavored pudding mix.

You can use this substitution according to the amount needed for the best result. It is important to know when using pudding mix the result may not be as rich and will depend on the quality of the pudding mix being used.

LEARN MORE: 5 Hot Calabrian Chili Substitutes

Arrowroot Flour

Arrowroot flour can be used instead of custard powder, and it is a great binding agent.

There are many ways that you can use this custard powder as a substitute.

If you desire a substitute without a smell or any taste, then arrowroot flour is the right choice.

It can be used in an assortment of recipes with stronger tasting ingredients, and this selection can be easily used without any conflict with the result.

Sweet Rice Flour

Sweet rice flour is very glutinous and is very sticky. It is used in many baked goods and is a preferred pairing with cakes.

You can use this custard powder substitute the same as you would tapioca powder substitutes.

The ratio is 1 to 1 for your recipe, whether you are baking or cooking. This means that you can use just as much sweet rice flour as a custard powder recipe substitute as you would tapioca flour.

Source: pfionline.com

Potato Starch Powder

Potato starch is made from the start of fresh potatoes, it can be used as a custard powder substitute.

You can use this substitute if you would like more texture, and it is similar to sweet rice flour.

Remember before using potato starch flour that it has less flavor than sweet rice flour, and is a great thickening agent that soaks up a lot of moisture.

It is typically used when baking and can be used in the same ratio as tapioca flour.

It is possible to substitute custard powder with an array of other ingredients, like a professional. The idea is to use the right ingredients according to the recipe being used.

For instance, if you’re using a recipe that requires more moisture, use a substitute that will not soak up your ingredients and make them too dry.

LEARN MORE: 6 Piquillo Peppers Substitutes

Likewise, it’s important to keep the taste in mind when using a custard powder substitute. All substitutes are not equal as far as taste is concerned, and each substitution can affect each recipe differently.

Feel free to experiment to find the right choice for each of your recipes that require custard powder.