10 Monterey-jack Cheese Substitutes (Number 4 Will Surely Surprise)

Monterey Jack can be found in many recipes, and it may be difficult to find substitutes for monetary jack cheese if you are not vigilant about the details. It has a distinctive taste and can have a milder profile.

It is usually made from cows’ pasteurized milk, and it belongs to the Monterey Jack family of cheeses. 

Depending on the quality, this cheese can feel creamy when warm and semi-hard in its natural state. This cheese has different variants, including cheese blends, dry, and Pepper Jack. This cheese is aged rather quickly, ranging from one to six months. 

The origin of Monterey Jack is from the town of Monterey, CA in the USA. Also, it is imperative to remember that the longer this cheese is aged the drier it becomes, and this affects the texture.

Monterey Jacks that have been aged up to six months can have a stronger taste as well. Yet, if you are looking for some amazing monetary jack cheese substitutes, give it a scroll.

Strong Substitutes for Monterey Jack Cheese

Swiss 

To replicate the creaminess of Monterey Jack, you can use Swiss cheese. It is imperative to know that there are over 450 types of Swiss cheeses, and each one has a distinctive taste.

Yet, each selection can be utilized as a substitute for Monterey Jack. 

One of the finest Swiss cheeses that you can select to take the place of Monterey Jack is Le Marechal. This selection is full-body flavored cheese. It may be paired with figs, olives, white wine, and different recipes that will not compete for its flavor.

If you enjoy Monterey Jack, then this selection will surprise you because you can use it in fondue. It is certainly an excellent choice as a Monterey Jack substitution that could be utilized in a variety of recipes.

Sbrinz

If you’re looking for a cheese that you can grade easily because of the texture, then Sbrinz can easily do the trick like Monterey Jack alternatives. This is a dry cheese that has a lot of flavors. 

Usually, it is aged for about a year and a half to thirty months for full flavor.

If you make different dishes that require Monterey Jack, this is a great substitute because it may be used in more dishes.

This includes pasta and a complement to a variety of wines. Sbrinz has an extended history that dates to before 70 AD. 

LEARN MORE: 10 Substitutes for Vegetable Oil in Brownies

Mallorca

Mallorca is a cheese of Spanish origin, and it may be made from sheep, goats, or cow’s milk. It has the same texture and consistency as Monterey Jack because it is naturally semi-hard.

Also, this cheese can be cut easily and has a smooth surface. It is important to note that Mallorca is slightly concentrated depending on its age.

This is a brilliant choice if you’re deciding to use a Monterey Jack as a standalone with a few drinks, and need a substitution. In addition to this, Mallorca makes an excellent addition to a charcuterie board. 

Colby

Colby is a cheese that is very similar to Monterey Jack because they’re both made with cow’s milk. This selection is a great substitute because of the semi-hard texture, which is similar to Monterey Jack. 

Also, it may be used in a variety of dishes that require Monterey Jack. It’s important to know that this cheese is softer than cheddar.

It has a mild flavor. It is great to use with a variety of snacks and salads.

It has different derivatives that include marble cheese and is related to Monterey Jack by extension. It is a cheese with an extensive history, and it dates back to the late 1800s and Colby, WI. 

Muenster

Muenster is a great substitution for Monterey Jack because the main resource that is used to make it is cow’s milk.

This selection could be a distant cousin to Monterey Jack because it may be used in a variety of recipes.

Muenster cheese can be utilized in quesadillas, pizza, sandwiches, and a variety of other foods.

LEARN MORE: 10 Custard Powder Substitute

Parmesan

Parmesan cheese that has not been aged for a long time can be utilized as a replacement for Monterey Jack.

It’s important to choose a parmesan that is young to get the texture of Monterey Jack. Also, a slice of younger-aged parmesan has a milder flavor. 

It is best to use this cheese for dishes that will not overpower the taste of the parmesan, and this is a cheese that can grade easily.

If you decide to use this selection instead of Monterey Jack, it’s important to know that there is a slight difference in taste. Overall, this is a great selection if you wish to substitute specific dishes that could meet the need for Monterey Jack.

White Cheddar 

White cheddar cheese is a great substitution for Monterey Jack because of the flavor. If you’re looking for a cheese that will melt easily, similar to Monterey Jack, then white cheddar should be used.

There are different varieties of cheddar cheese, including orange or yellow cheddar. 

Cheddar has an excellent rich creamy flavor that’s more pronounced in comparison to Monterey Jack. If you decide to use this as a substitution, remember that smaller amounts of cheddar can be utilized to replicate Monterey Jack.

LEARN MORE: 10 Matzo Meal Substitutes

Gouda

Gouda has a mild flavor like Monterey Jack, and instead of using cow’s milk, sometimes it is made with goat’s milk. Gouda typically has a stronger flavor and can be compared to extendedly aged Monterey Jack.

This is a cheese that is from the Netherlands (specifically South Holland) and has a hard to semihard texture.

Also, it has a long history that dates back to 1184, and is one of the oldest cheeses recorded and still currently made for consumption. Typically, the age of time can range from one month to three years.

Young Gouda cheese is typically made within four weeks, and as it ages the taste can become more pronounced with notes of sweetness.

If you use this as a substitution for Monterey Jack, it’s important to get gouda aged between four to six weeks. The aging process impacts the flavor and can affect the substitution. 

Havarti

Havarti is a cheese that has been aged for up to three months and is originally from Denmark. Like Monterey Jack, the source of making it is derivative from the milk of cows.

Havarti cheese is an excellent substitute if you plan to melt Monterey Jack and need a substitute.

This is because the texture of Havarti cheese is usually semi-soft, and it has a buttery-like aroma.

It is key to know that a younger Havarti cheese is best for Monterey Jack substitution because of the milder taste. Havarti cheese can taste creamy and when melted it can work as a replacement for Monterey Jack.

Provel 

Provel is a cheese that originated in the United States in Saint Louis. The resource that is used to make Provel cheese is cow’s milk.

It may be similar to the Monterey Jack when it is melted. It is important to remember if you decide to use Provel cheese that it has a lower melting point.

As a substitution for Monterey Jack, you can use it in a variety of dishes, including pizza, salads, and Italian dishes. There is almost no limit to the creativity that could be utilized when using Provel cheese.

LEARN MORE: 10 Pinto Bean Substitutes

Conclusion

When you are seeking Monetary jack cheese substitutes, it is important to keep not only flavor but the texture in mind for your dishes. The cheeses listed above have different and distinct flavor profiles that are related to Monterey Jack cheese substitutes.

However, we prefer using the Colby cheese as it has almost the same taste and flavor as the monetary jack cheese.